East–West Shrine Bowl

(Redirected from East-West Shrine Game)

The East–West Shrine Bowl is a postseason college football all-star game that has been played annually since 1925; through January 2019, it was known as the East–West Shrine Game.[2] The game is sponsored by the fraternal group Shriners International, and the net proceeds are earmarked to some of the Shrine's charitable works, most notably the Shriners Hospitals for Children. The game's slogan is "Strong Legs Run That Weak Legs May Walk."

East–West Shrine Bowl
The game's logo, featuring a young girl recovering from surgery walking with Boston College player Mike Esposito before the 1974 game.[1]
StadiumFord Center at The Star (2024–future)
LocationFrisco, Texas (2024–future)
Previous stadiumsKezar Stadium (1925–1941, 1943–1968, 1971–1973)
Stanford Stadium (1969, 1974–2000)
Tulane Stadium (1942)
Oakland Coliseum (1970)
AT&T Park (2001–2005)
Alamodome (2006)
Reliant Stadium (2007)
Robertson Stadium (2008–2009)
Orlando Citrus Bowl (2010–2011)
Tropicana Field (2012–2020)
Allegiant Stadium (2022–2023)
Previous locationsSan Francisco, California (1925–1941, 1943–1968, 1971–1973, 2001–2005)
New Orleans, Louisiana (1942)
Stanford, California (1969, 1974–2000)
Oakland, California (1971)
San Antonio, Texas (2006)
Houston, Texas (2007–2009)
Orlando, Florida (2010–2011)
St. Petersburg, Florida (2012–2020)
Paradise, Nevada (2022–2023)
Operated1925–present
Sponsors
Shriners (1925–present)
Former names
East–West Shrine Game (1925–2019)
2023 matchup
East vs. West (West 12–3)
2024 matchup
East vs. West (West 26–11)

Teams consist of players from colleges in the Eastern United States vs. the Western United States. Players must be college seniors who are eligible to play for their schools.[3] The game and the practice sessions leading up to it attract dozens of scouts from professional teams. Since 1985, Canadian players playing in Canadian university football have also been invited (even though U Sports and the NCAA play by different football codes). As such, this is the only current bowl or all-star game in either the Canadian or American college football schedules to include players from both Canadian and American universities.

The game has been played in various locations. Most editions have been held in California, although the most recent edition played there was in 2005. In June 2023, organizers announced the game would move to Ford Center at The Star in Frisco, Texas, starting with the 2024 edition.

Since 1979, the game has been played in January, and has been played on January 10 or later since 1986. The later game dates allow players from teams whose schools were involved in bowl games to participate, which is important, as these teams often have some of the very best players.

History

20th century

For most of its history, the game was played in the San Francisco Bay Area, usually at San Francisco's Kezar Stadium or Stanford Stadium at Stanford University, with Pacific Bell Park/SBC Park (now Oracle Park) as a host in its final years in Northern California. For more than half of the games played in the Bay Area, entertainment was provided by the marching band from Santa Cruz High School.[4]

In January 1942, the game was played in New Orleans, due to the December 7, 1941, Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. This one-year relocation was based upon fears that playing the game on the west coast could make the contest and the stadium a potential target for an additional attack. The game, originally planned for January 1 in San Francisco, was played on January 3 at Tulane Stadium, two days after the 1942 Sugar Bowl was held there.[5]

During this era, the game was not restrict to college seniors—for example, the January 1944 edition of the game featured Robert Hoernschemeyer, Dean Sensanbaugher, and Herman Wedemeyer, each then college freshmen.[6]

A similar all-star game, the North–South Shrine Game, was played in Miami from 1948 to 1973, and a final time in Pontiac, Michigan, in 1976.

21st century

Kickoff of the 2017 game at Tropicana Field

In 2006, the game moved to Texas, leaving the San Francisco Bay area for the first time since 1942, and was played at the Alamodome in San Antonio. The growth of cable television meant NFL scouts could now view players around the country, making postseason all-star games less important. Even so, the game's organizers relaxed efforts towards attracting top players to the game, meaning many of college football's best players went to the Senior Bowl instead. In 2007, the game relocated to Houston and was played at Reliant Stadium, home of the NFL's Houston Texans, to be closer to one of the 22 Shriners Hospitals for Children; Texas has two Shriner's hospitals, one in Houston and the other in Galveston. The 2008 and 2009 games were held at Robertson Stadium on the campus of the University of Houston.[7][8]

In 2010, the game moved to Florida, and was held at the Citrus Bowl in Orlando. Television coverage moved from ESPN/ESPN2 to the NFL Network, starting with the 2011 game.[9] After two years in Orlando, the 2012 game was held at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg; it was the sixth different venue (in five cities and three states) in a span of eight contests.

Starting with the January 2017 game, the NFL supplies coaching staffs for the game, drawing from assistant coaches of teams who did not advance to the NFL postseason, and the game is now officiated by NFL officials.[10] The game is played under NFL rules, with some restrictions, such as no motion or shifts by the offense, and no stunts or blitzes by the defense.[11] Prior to the January 2020 playing, organizers renamed the game from East–West Shrine Game to East–West Shrine Bowl.[2]

The 2021 edition of the game, which had been scheduled for January 23, was cancelled due to concerns related to the COVID-19 pandemic.[12]

In July 2021, it was announced that Allegiant Stadium would host the East–West Shrine Bowl on February 3, 2022; the game was scheduled as part of festivities for the 2022 Pro Bowl being held there the following Sunday.[13]

In June 2023, organizers announced that the game would move to Ford Center at The Star in Frisco, Texas, for its 2024 playing.[14]

Game results

Through the February 2024 game (99 editions, 98 games played), the West leads all-time with 54 wins to the East's 39 wins, while 5 games have tied.[15][16][17]

No.DateWinnerScoreLocationNotes
51January 3, 1976West21–14Stanford, California
52January 2, 1977West30–14Stanford, California
53December 31, 1977West23–3Stanford, California
54January 6, 1979East56–17Stanford, California
55January 5, 1980West20–10Stanford, California
56January 10, 1981East21–3Stanford, California
57January 9, 1982West20–13Stanford, California
58January 15, 1983East26–25Stanford, California
59January 7, 1984East27–19Stanford, California
60January 5, 1985West21–10Stanford, California
61January 11, 1986East18–7Stanford, California
62January 10, 1987West24–21Stanford, California
63January 16, 1988West16–13Stanford, California
64January 15, 1989East24–6Stanford, California
65January 21, 1990West22–21Stanford, California
66January 26, 1991West24–21Stanford, California
67January 19, 1992West14–6Stanford, California
68January 24, 1993East31–17Stanford, California
69January 15, 1994West29–28Stanford, California
70January 14, 1995West30–28Stanford, California
71January 13, 1996West34–18Stanford, California
72January 11, 1997East17–13Stanford, California
73January 10, 1998West24–7Stanford, California
74January 16, 1999East20–10Stanford, California
75January 15, 2000East35–21Stanford, California
76January 13, 2001West20–10San Francisco
77January 12, 2002West21–13San Francisco
78January 11, 2003East20–17San Francisco
79January 10, 2004West28–7San FranciscoNotes
80January 15, 2005East45–27San FranciscoNotes
81January 21, 2006West35–31San AntonioNotes
82January 20, 2007West21–3HoustonNotes
83January 19, 2008West31–13HoustonNotes
84January 17, 2009East24–19HoustonNotes
85January 23, 2010East13–10Orlando, FloridaNotes
86January 22, 2011East25–8Orlando, FloridaNotes
87January 21, 2012West24–17St. Petersburg, FloridaNotes
88January 19, 2013West28–13St. Petersburg, FloridaNotes
89January 18, 2014East23–13St. Petersburg, FloridaNotes
90January 17, 2015East19–3St. Petersburg, FloridaNotes
91January 23, 2016West29–9St. Petersburg, FloridaNotes
92January 21, 2017West10–3St. Petersburg, FloridaNotes
93January 20, 2018West14–10St. Petersburg, FloridaNotes
94January 19, 2019West21–17St. Petersburg, FloridaNotes
95January 18, 2020East31–27St. Petersburg, FloridaNotes
96January 23, 2021Canceled[12]
97February 3, 2022West25–24Paradise, NevadaNotes
98February 2, 2023West12–3Paradise, NevadaNotes
99February 1, 2024West26–11Frisco, TexasNotes

† For the December 1925 game, NCAA records list a 7–0 final score,[16] while contemporary newspaper accounts report 6–0.[18]

MVPs

The game first named a Most Valuable Player for the January 1945 playing (Bob Waterfield, UCLA quarterback), and named a single MVP through the December 1952 game. Starting with the January 1954 game, two MVPs are selected for each game; they receive the William H. Coffman Award for Most Outstanding Offensive Player, and the E. Jack Spaulding Award for Most Outstanding Defensive Player.[19] Coffman was managing director of the game for 40 years, while Spaulding was one of the organizers of the inaugural playing of the game.[19] MVPs starting with the January 2000 game are listed below; a complete list is provided on the official website.[20]

YearOffensive MVPCollegePositionDefensive MVPCollegePosition
2000Marcus KnightMichiganWRErik FlowersArizona StateDE
2001Steve SmithUtahWRLeo BarnesSouthern MississippiDB
2002Deonce WhitakerSan Jose StateRBEverick RawlsTexasLB
2003Donald LeeMississippi StateTETully Banta-CainCalDE
2004Ryan DinwiddieBoise StateQBBrandon ChillarUCLALB
2005Stefan LeForsLouisvilleQBAlex GreenDukeS
2006Reggie McNealTexas A&MQBJames WycheSyracuseDE
2007Jeff RoweNevadaQBDan BazuinCentral MichiganDE
2008Josh JohnsonSan DiegoQBSpencer LarsenArizonaLB
2009Marlon LuckyNebraskaRBMichael TauiliiliDukeLB
2010Mike KafkaNorthwesternQBO'Brien SchofieldWisconsinDE
2011Delone CarterSyracuseRBMartin ParkerRichmondDT
2012Lennon CreerLouisiana TechRBNick SukayPenn StateCB
2013Chad BumphisMississippi StateWRNigel MaloneKansas StateCB
2014Jimmy GaroppoloEastern IllinoisQBEthan WestbrooksWest Texas A&MDE
2015Marvin KlossSouth FloridaKZa'Darius SmithKentuckyDE
2016Vernon AdamsOregonQBMichael CaputoWisconsinS
2017Elijah McGuireLouisiana–LafayetteRBTrey HendricksonFlorida AtlanticDE
2018Daurice FountainNorthern IowaWRNatrell JamersonWisconsinS
2019Terry GodwinGeorgiaWRJustin HollinsOregonLB
2020Benny LeMayCharlotteRBLuther KirkIllinois StateS
2022E. J. PerryBrownQBDiego FagotNavyLB
2023Jake MoodyMichiganKTrey Dean IIIFloridaS
2024Frank Gore Jr.[21]Southern MissRBJarius Monroe[22]TulaneCB

Canadian invitees

Although the game is an American football competition, players of Canadian university football, contested under Canadian football rules, have been invited to each game played since 1985, when Calgary Dinos offensive lineman Tom Spoletini played. Usually, Canadian players on the West team come from Canada West schools, while Canadian players on the East team are from the other three Canadian conferences (Ontario University Athletics, Atlantic University Sport, and Quebec Student Sport Federation). One exception was Sean McEwen of the Calgary Dinos (a Canada West school), who played on the East squad in the 2016 game. The only Canadian team that competed under American football rules is the now-defunct Simon Fraser Red Leafs; the only Simon Fraser player to be invited to the game is Ibrahim Khan, who played in 2004 when Simon Fraser still played Canadian football.

Through the 2024 game, the Calgary Dinos have had the most invitees, with 13.

In 2024, the lone Canadian invitee was Qwan'tez Stiggers, an American who did not play college football but instead became a professional player for the Toronto Argonauts of the Canadian Football League.[23][24]

Canadian invitees to the East–West Shrine Bowl 
YearWest teamEast team
1985Tom Spoletini (OL, Calgary Dinos)(none)
1986Kent Warnock (DE, Calgary Dinos)Mike Schad (OT, Queen's Gaels)
1987Leo Groenewegen (OT, UBC Thunderbirds)Louie Godry (OL, Guelph Gryphons)
1988Craig Watson (OL, Calgary Dinos)Pierre Vercheval (OL, Western Mustangs)
1989Brent Korte (DE, Alberta Golden Bears)Leroy Blugh (LB, Bishop's Gaiters)
1990Mark Singer (LB, Alberta Golden Bears)Chris Gioskos (OL, Ottawa Gee-Gees)
1991Mike Pavelec (OL, Calgary Dinos)Paul Vajda (OL, Concordia Stingers)
1992Jason Rauhaus (DE, Manitoba Bisons)Chris Morris (OL, Toronto Varsity Blues)
1993Chris Konrad (DE, Calgary Dinos)Mike O'Shea (LB, Guelph Gryphons)
1994Travis Serke (OT, Saskatchewan Huskies)Val St. Germain (OG, McGill Redmen)
1995Rohn Meyer (OG, Calgary Dinos)Matthieu Quiviger (OT, McGill Redmen)
1996Don Blair (WR, Calgary Dinos)Harry Van Hofwegen (DT, Carleton Ravens)
1997Ben Fairbrother (OL, Calgary Dinos)Mark Farraway (DL, St. Francis Xavier X-Men)
1998Bob Beveridge (OL, UBC Thunderbirds)Dave Miller-Johnston (P/K, Concordia Stingers)
1999Scott Flory (OT, Saskatchewan Huskies)Cameron Legault (DT, Carleton Ravens)
2000Kevin Lefsrud (OT, Saskatchewan Huskies)Kojo Millington (DE, Wilfrid Laurier Golden Hawks)
2001Carlo Panaro (OL, Alberta Golden Bears)Randy Chevrier (DL, McGill Redmen)
2002Jason Clermont (IR, Regina Rams)Kojo Aidoo (RB, McMaster Marauders)
2003Israel Idonije (DT, Manitoba Bisons)Adam MacDonald (LB, St. Francis Xavier X-Men)
2004Ibrahim Khan (OL, Simon Fraser Clan football)Carl Gourgues (OL, Laval Rouge et Or)
2005Nick Johansson (DT, UBC Thunderbirds)Jesse Lumsden (RB, McMaster Marauders)
2006Daniel Federkeil (DE, Calgary Dinos)Andy Fantuz (WR, Western Mustangs)
2007Jordan Rempel (OL, Saskatchewan Huskies)Chris Best (OL, Waterloo Warriors)
2008Dylan Barker (S, Saskatchewan Huskies)
Brendon LaBatte (OG, Regina Rams)
Samuel Giguère (WR, Sherbrooke Vert et Or)
Eric Maranda (LB, Laval Rouge et Or)
2009Simeon Rottier (OT, Alberta Golden Bears)Etienne Légaré (DT, Laval Rouge et Or)
2010Jordan Sisco (WR/SB, Regina Rams)Matt Morencie (C, Windsor Lancers)
2011Anthony Parker (SB, Calgary Dinos)Matt O'Donnell (OT, Queen's Gaels)
2012Ben Heenan (OT, Saskatchewan Huskies)
Akiem Hicks (DE, Regina Rams)
Arnaud Gascon-Nadon (DE, Laval Rouge et Or)
2013Kirby Fabien (OL, Calgary Dinos)Matt Sewell (OT, McMaster Marauders)
2014Evan Gill (DL, Manitoba Bisons)Laurent Duvernay-Tardif (OT, McGill Redmen)
2015Addison Richards (WR, Regina Rams)Daryl Waud (DL, Western Mustangs)
2016David Onyemata (DE, Manitoba Bisons)Sean McEwen, (OL, Calgary Dinos)
Charles Vaillancourt (OL, Laval Rouge et Or)
2017Geoff Gray (OG, Manitoba Bisons)Antony Auclair (TE, Laval Rouge et Or)
2018Mark Korte (OL, Alberta Golden Bears)Regis Cibasu (WR, Montreal Carabins)
2019Joel Van Pelt (DT, Calgary Dinos)Mathieu Betts (DE, Laval Rouge et Or)
2020Carter O'Donnell (OT, Alberta Golden Bears)
Marc-Antoine Dequoy (S, Montreal Carabins)
(none)
2022Deionte Knight (DL, Western Mustangs)(none)
2023Theo Benedet (OL, UBC Thunderbirds)(none)
2024Qwan'tez Stiggers (CB, Toronto Argonauts [CFL])(none)

Hall of fame

A hall of fame was established in 2002, with additional inductees typically named in the weeks leading up to each annual playing.[25] Through 2024 inductees, there are currently 64 members of the hall of fame.

YearQtyInductees (Game no. played in)
20026Dick Butkus (No. 40), Gerald Ford (No. 10), Eddie LeBaron (No. 25), Ollie Matson (No. 27), Volney Peters (No. 26), Dick Stanfel (No. 26)
20036Hugh McElhenny (No. 28), Craig Morton (No. 40), Merlin Olsen (No. 37), Alan Page (No. 42), Leslie Richter (No. 27), Gene Washington (No. 44)
20045Chris Burford (No. 35), Mike Garrett (No. 41), Gino Marchetti (No. 27), Tom Matte (No. 36), Ed White (No. 44)
20051Pat Tillman (No. 73)
20064Raymond Berry (No. 30), Joe Greene (No. 44), Mike Haynes (No. 51), Bob Lilly (No. 36)
20074Joe DeLamielleure (No. 48), Gale Sayers (No. 40), Paul Warfield (No. 39), Randy White (No. 50)
20086Dave Butz (No. 48), Carl Eller (No. 39), Forrest Gregg (No. 31), E.J. Holub (No. 36), Lenny Moore (No. 31), Larry Wilson (No. 35)
20094Jerry Kramer (No. 33), Charley Taylor (No. 39), Brad Van Pelt (No. 48), Doug Williams (No. 53)
20104Larry Csonka (No. 43), James Groh (No. 21), Jim Walden (No. 35), Kellen Winslow (No. 54)[26]
20112Buck Belue (No. 57), Tom Flick (No. 56)
20122Martín Gramática (No. 74), Joey Harrington (No. 77)
20132Buddy Curry (No. 55), Steve Bartkowski (No. 50)
20142Tony Berti (No. 70), Steve Atwater (No. 64)
20152Tommie Frazier (No. 71), Jim Hanifan (No. 30)
20162Rickey Jackson (No. 56), Chris Chandler (No. 63)
20172Robert Porcher (No. 67), Mark Rypien (No. 61)
20183Brett Favre (No. 66), Willie Roaf (No. 68), Gary Huff (No. 48)[27]
20192Troy Vincent (No. 67), Barry Smith (No. 48)[28]
20202Will Shields (No. 68), Dan Pastorini (No. 46)[29]
20231Nate Burleson (No. 78)[30]
20242Steve Sarkisian (No. 72), Steve Smith Sr. (No. 76)[31]

Inductees range from having played in game No. 10 (January 1935) to game No. 78 (January 2003), with game No. 48 (December 1972) having the most players honored, five.

Pat Tillman Award

Pat Tillman
2011 recipient Josh McNary

Game organizers initiated a Pat Tillman Award in 2005, the year that Tillman was posthumously inducted to the game's hall of fame, to recognize "a player who best exemplifies character, intelligence, sportsmanship and service."[32]

YearPlayerPos.College
2005Morgan ScalleySUtah
2006Charlie PeprahSAlabama
2007Kyle ShotwellLBCal Poly
2008Justin TryonCBArizona State
2009Collin MooneyFBArmy
2010Mike McLaughlinLBBoston College
2011Josh McNaryLBArmy
2012Tauren PooleRBTennessee
2013Keith PoughLBHoward
2014Gabe IkardCOklahoma
2015Jake RyanLBMichigan
2016Keenan ReynoldsQBNavy
2017Weston SteelhammerSAir Force
2018J. T. BarrettQBOhio State
2019Cody BartonLBUtah
2020James Morgan[33]QBFIU
2022Jack Coan[34]QBNotre Dame
2023Derek Parish[35]DEHouston
2024Trey Taylor[36]SAir Force

Head coaches who played in the game

Several Shrine Bowl players have gone on to serve as a head coach in a later Shrine Bowl.[37]

PersonAs playerAs coach
Jeff Cravath1927USC1949USC
Chuck Taylor1943Stanford1954Stanford
Eddie Crowder1952Oklahoma1971Colorado
Jim Walden1960Wyoming1985Washington State
Joe Tiller1963Montana State2005Purdue

References