Tearin' Up My Heart

"Tearin' Up My Heart" was originally pitched for the Backstreet Boys to record, but was instead given to NSYNC.^[1] It was written by Max Martin and the producer Kristian Lundin in a three-day period after the band's debut single "I Want You Back" started appearing on several European charts. Their German record label, BMG Ariola, wanted the next single to sound similar to "I Want You Back", but catered towards an American audience.^[2] "Tearin' Up My Heart" was recorded at Cheiron Studios in 1996.^[3] Lundin overslept on the recording day and was subsequently awoken by Martin and Denniz Pop. NSYNC arrived in Stockholm during the previous night for one day, before being scheduled in Germany the next morning. The song's recording occurred throughout the night until 6 a.m. without any rest breaks, with JC Chasez as the final member to perform the concluding takes.^[2] NSYNC were excited about "Tearin' Up My Heart", with Chasez stating that it would help bookend their concerts with "two hit songs".^[4] "Tearin' Up My Heart" was released in Germany as a CD single on February 10, 1997.^[5] In the United States, the song was only released to contemporary hit radio and rhythmic contemporary radio stations on June 23, 1998.^[6] It was released in Australia as NSYNC's second single in March 1999,^[7] and in the United Kingdom as a CD and cassette single on June 14, 1999.^[8]

Musically, "Tearin' Up My Heart" is a dance-pop^[9][10] and teen pop song,^[11] with a pop-sounding melody and a funk-styled pre-verse breakdown. It contains a hook, a "hard-hitting beat", and a refrain with vocal harmonies provided by the NSYNC members. Chasez provides the lead vocals in the song,^[12] while Justin Timberlake performs the vocals in the second verse.^[13] The lyrics depict the ambiguous future of a romantic relationship,^[14] with Chasez stating that they represent "the double-edged sword of love".^[15]

Music critics considered "Tearin' Up My Heart" to be an uptempo song.^[16][17][18] Quad-City Times staff praised the production for containing "engaging personality" in comparison to other boy bands, but critiqued the lyrics for being "mildly clichéd", and the song for not altering the direction of pop music.^[19] Chuck Campbell of Naples Daily News similarly commended the "near-memorable" production and "catchy" refrain of "Tearin' Up My Heart", although he commented that they were used to mask the song's "lack of imagination".^[10] Writing for The Indianapolis Star, David Lindquist questioned the production for sounding too similar to late-1980s inspirations such as Rick Astley, and opined that every NSYNC member did not have "an exceptional voice".^[20]

VH1 listed "Tearin' Up My Heart" at number 30 on their "100 Greatest Songs of the '90s" listicle in 2007.^[21] Writing for Billboard, Taylor Weatherby placed the song at number five on their 2018 listicle of "The 100 Greatest Boy Band Songs of All Time", stating that it contained "higher energy", a "sharper hook", and was "more awe-inspiring" than "I Want You Back".^[12] In 2023, Billboard magazine ranked "Tearin' Up My Heart" among the "500 Best Pop Songs of All Time".^[22]

"Tearin' Up My Heart" debuted at number ten on the German Singles Chart dated February 24, 1997, where it peaked at number four for one week and remained on the chart for 17 weeks.^[23] It ranked at the number thirty position on the 1997 year-end chart in the country.^[24] The song peaked at number four on the Austrian Ö3 Austria Top 40 on April 20, 1997,^[25] and subsequently placed at number thirty-three on the country's year-end chart in 1997.^[26] In the Netherlands, "Tearin' Up My Heart" entered at number fifty-six on the Dutch Single Top 100 chart issued April 12, 1997, where it remained for 10 weeks and peaked at number thirty-one.^[27]

"Tearin' Up My Heart" first appeared at number forty on the UK Singles Chart dated September 13, 1997, and charted for two weeks. On the chart dated June 26, 1999, the song returned to the chart at the number nine peak and remained for 10 weeks.^[28] "Tearin' Up My Heart" was certified silver by the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) on April 6, 2018, for sales of over 200,000 equivalent-sales units in the United Kingdom.^[29] In Scotland, the song debuted at the number ten peak on the Scottish Singles Chart dated June 20, 1999.^[30] "Tearin' Up My Heart" bowed at number twenty on the Australian ARIA Singles Chart issued April 25, 1999, where it remained for 12 weeks.^[31]

Upon its release in the United States, "Tearin' Up My Heart" was ineligible to appear on the Billboard Hot 100 until a rule change was implemented to allow songs without physical releases to chart on December 5, 1998,^[32] peaking at number fifty-nine that week.^[33] It peaked at number six on the Mainstream Top 40 chart dated September 21, 1998.^[34] In Canada, the song peaked at number three on the RPM Top Singles chart dated August 16, 1998,^[35] and was certified platinum by Music Canada (MC), for track-equivalent sales of 80,000 units in the country.^[36]

An accompanying music video for "Tearin' Up My Heart" was directed by Stefan Ruzowitzky from 1996 to 1997,^[37] and filmed in Florida. It was released in Europe in February 1997,^[2] and aired in the United States on the debut episode of Total Request Live (TRL) on September 14, 1998.^[38] The video depicts the NSYNC members dancing inside a warehouse, playing basketball, and taking photos using a Polaroid camera.^[2] They additionally participate in a photo shoot, perform acrobatics, eat pizza, and are sprawled out next to grayscale photographs. Chasez is seen performing with a guitar in one scene.^[39] Each member appears in identical black and white outfits.^[40] Akron Beacon Journal staff writer Glenn Gamboa described the video as "attractive".^[41] The MTV premiere of "Tearin' Up My Heart" in the United States altered a scene from the original European release, which otherwise remained intact. The scene depicted an adolescent female lying next to Timberlake on a bed, with the former digitally erased under orders from NSYNC's record label to maintain their innocent image.^[42] The music video was nominated at the 1999 MTV Video Music Awards for Best Pop Video, Best Group Video, and Viewer's Choice.^[43][44]

"Tearin' Up My Heart" was included on the encore of the NSYNC in Concert tour, where the NSYNC members were harnessed on wires and performed somersaults,^[45] flips,^[46][47] and upside down splits to conclude each concert. Writing for The Dispatch following the Quad Cities concert in 1999, Marc Nesseler opined that the song had "the most enjoyable synchronized dance steps of the night".^[48] During the No Strings Attached Tour, a video of a TRL parody segment with MTV video jockey Ananda Lewis was aired, who introduced "Tearin' Up My Heart" as the winner of a pre-determined live fan poll over songs including "Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star", "Yankee Doodle", and "Three Blind Mice".^[49][50][51] NSYNC performed "Tearin' Up My Heart" on the PopOdyssey tour as an abridged version,^[52][53][54] and on the Celebrity Tour with intense choreography.^[55]

During MTV's Spring Break coverage on March 19, 1999, NSYNC performed "Tearin' Up My Heart" on the program's "Fashionably Loud" segment. The members wore cargo pants with buttoned shirts, as Timberlake wore a baby blue shirt and Chris Kirkpatrick sported upside down visors.^[56] At the 1999 MTV Video Music Awards, Britney Spears and NSYNC performed together on the same stage,^[57] which was their debut appearance at the MTV Video Music Awards (VMAs). Host Chris Rock yelled out "Are you ready for some real lip-synching?", as he introduced both performers on stage and subsequently surprised music journalists.^[58][59] Spears first performed a remix of "...Baby One More Time" in black leather attire,^[58][60] as NSYNC transitioned into "Tearin' Up My Heart" using the existing classroom setup from the previous performance.^[61][62]

The remaining NSYNC members without Timberlake appeared at the Coachella Valley Music and Arts Festival on April 14, 2019, to perform with headliner Ariana Grande.^[63] Both artists teased a collaboration during the afternoon on Twitter before their performance.^[64] The members rehearsed for one and a half days, and delivered live vocals at the event.^[65] They appeared as Grande's surprise guests to sing the bridge of "Break Up with Your Girlfriend, I'm Bored", which sampled "It Makes Me Ill" from their second studio album No Strings Attached. They then performed "Tearin' Up My Heart", with Grande substituting for Timberlake's vocals in the second verse and simultaneously dancing to the song's choreography.^[13][66] The accompanying video screen resembled a VHS tape with ripples and numbers,^[67] as NSYNC's appearance at the event was positively received by the loud crowd.^[68][69][70] Gab Ginsberg of Billboard opined that Grande's performance of "Tearin' Up My Heart" was a "highlight" from her headlining set.^[13]

"Tearin' Up My Heart" was used on NSYNC's episode of Becoming, an MTV program where fans recreate a music video filmed by the original artist.^[71] Over 100 people from Southern California physically appeared to audition, while over 200 people across the United States sent in audition tapes.^[72] The song was also given to the Massive Monkees on the fourth season of America's Best Dance Crew as part of the VMAs challenge in Week 6.^[73] The group intended to show "intensity" in their performance,^[74] which was praised by judge Chasez as "one of their best performances".^[75]

Credits adapted from the back cover of "Tearin' Up My Heart".^[3]

Recording

• Recorded at Cheiron Studios, Stockholm, Sweden
• Produced for Cheiron Productions, 1996

Personnel

• Kristian Lundin – music, lyrics, production
• Max Martin – music, lyrics
• Moritz Teichmann – photography