| Week | First Star | Second Star | Third Star |
|---|
| October 6, 2013[1] | Alexander Ovechkin
(Washington Capitals) | Lars Eller
(Montreal Canadiens) | Marc-Andre Fleury
(Pittsburgh Penguins) |
| October 13, 2013[2] | Tomas Hertl
(San Jose Sharks) | Semyon Varlamov
Jean-Sebastien Giguere
(Colorado Avalanche) | Sidney Crosby
(Pittsburgh Penguins) |
| October 20, 2013[3] | Jonas Gustavsson
(Detroit Red Wings) | Sidney Crosby
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Patrick Marleau
(San Jose Sharks) |
| October 27, 2013[4] | Steven Stamkos
(Tampa Bay Lightning) | Phil Kessel
(Toronto Maple Leafs) | Ryan Kesler
(Vancouver Canucks) |
| November 3, 2013[5] | Jason Pominville
(Minnesota Wild) | Marc-Andre Fleury
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Jason Chimera
(Washington Capitals) |
| November 10, 2013[6] | Robin Lehner
(Ottawa Senators) | Frederik Andersen
(Anaheim Ducks) | Patrick Sharp
(Chicago Blackhawks) |
| November 17, 2013[7] | Ben Scrivens
(Los Angeles Kings) | Tyler Seguin
(Dallas Stars) | Josh Harding
(Minnesota Wild) |
| November 24, 2013[8] | Evgeni Malkin
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Max Pacioretty
(Montreal Canadiens) | Devan Dubnyk
(Edmonton Oilers) |
| December 1, 2013[9] | Evgeni Malkin
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Niklas Kronwall
(Detroit Red Wings) | Duncan Keith
(Chicago Blackhawks) |
| December 8, 2013[10] | Jeff Skinner
(Carolina Hurricanes) | Taylor Hall
(Edmonton Oilers) | Roberto Luongo
(Vancouver Canucks) |
| December 15, 2013[11] | Alexander Ovechkin
(Washington Capitals) | Martin Jones
(Los Angeles Kings) | Carter Hutton
(Nashville Predators) |
| December 22, 2013[12] | Chris Stewart
(St. Louis Blues) | Sidney Crosby
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Matt Duchene
(Colorado Avalanche) |
| December 29, 2013[13] | Patrick Sharp
(Chicago Blackhawks) | Ryan Miller
(Buffalo Sabres) | James Neal
(Pittsburgh Penguins) |
| January 5, 2014[14] | Jeff Skinner
(Carolina Hurricanes) | Brian Elliott
(St. Louis Blues) | Ryan Suter
(Minnesota Wild) |
| January 12, 2014[15] | John Tavares
(New York Islanders) | Jonas Hiller
(Anaheim Ducks) | Henrik Lundqvist
(New York Rangers) |
| January 19, 2014[16] | Martin St. Louis
(Tampa Bay Lightning) | Jonathan Quick
(Los Angeles Kings) | Corey Crawford
(Chicago Blackhawks) |
| January 26, 2014[17] | Kari Lehtonen
(Dallas Stars) | Gustav Nyquist
(Detroit Red Wings) | Andrej Sekera
(Carolina Hurricanes) |
| February 2, 2014[18] | Zach Parise
(Minnesota Wild) | Phil Kessel
(Toronto Maple Leafs) | Mikael Backlund
(Calgary Flames) |
| February 9, 2014[19] | Carey Price
(Montreal Canadiens) | Kari Lehtonen
(Dallas Stars) | Jarome Iginla
(Boston Bruins) |
| March 2, 2014[20] | Johan Franzen
(Detroit Red Wings) | Adam Henrique
(New Jersey Devils) | Darcy Kuemper
(Minnesota Wild) |
| March 9, 2014[21] | Tyler Seguin
(Dallas Stars) | Artem Anisimov
(Columbus Blue Jackets) | Adam Henrique
(New Jersey Devils) |
| March 16, 2014[22] | Sergei Bobrovsky
(Columbus Blue Jackets) | Kyle Okposo
(New York Islanders) | Antti Niemi
(San Jose Sharks) |
| March 23, 2014[23] | Gustav Nyquist
(Detroit Red Wings) | Henrik Lundqvist
(New York Rangers) | Jarome Iginla
(Boston Bruins) |
| March 30, 2014[24] | Kyle Turris
(Ottawa Senators) | Patrice Bergeron
(Boston Bruins) | T. J. Oshie
(St. Louis Blues) |
| April 6, 2014[25] | Taylor Hall
(Edmonton Oilers) | Semyon Varlamov
(Colorado Avalanche) | Max Pacioretty
(Montreal Canadiens) |
| April 13, 2014[26] | Anders Lindback
(Tampa Bay Lightning) | John Gibson
(Anaheim Ducks) | Ryan Johansen
(Columbus Blue Jackets) |