In Person!

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
Allmusic	[5]

Billboard magazine chose In Person! as one of their "Spotlight Winners of the Week" in March 1959, and wrote that "The drive of the Bennett vocals is excellently paced by the swingin' Basie crew. Tunes are nicely paced and varied. It's an exciting set that builds track after track".^[6]

In sharp contast, Ralph J. Gleason in the July 1959 edition of HiFi Review called the record "disappointing" and opined that it "brings out all the faults of Bennett," that "Tony Bennett really can't sing well enough to earn the support of a band like this" and that the performance suffered from "poor intonation, poor phrasing and great determination to be dramatic."^[7]

Bruce Eder positively reviewed the 1994 re-issue of In Person! for Allmusic, and wrote that "Bennett's sensitively nuanced intonation in the opening of "Pennies from Heaven" is now up close and personal, while the band's beat in the second half of the song is now crisper and more solid than ever. Ralph Sharon, Bennett's usual accompanist, is handling the piano chores (while Basie himself is credited as leader), and his finely articulated playing is also brought out crisply on "Lost in the Stars" and other tracks. It's all worth hearing, and more often than just once—it was records like this, as reconstituted properly for CD, that constituted the absolute golden end of the pop legacy of the late '50s."^[2]

1. "Just in Time" (Betty Comden, Adolph Green, Jule Styne) – 1:45
2. "When I Fall in Love" (Edward Heyman, Victor Young) – 2:20
3. "Taking a Chance on Love" (Vernon Duke, Ted Fetter, John La Touche) – 1:57
4. "Without a Song" (Edward Eliscu, Billy Rose, Vincent Youmans) – 3:06
5. "Fascinating Rhythm" (Gershwin, Ira Gershwin) – 1:30
6. "(In My) Solitude" (Eddie DeLange, Duke Ellington, Irving Mills) – 3:35
7. "Pennies from Heaven" (Johnny Burke, Arthur Johnston) – 2:33
8. "Lost in the Stars" (Maxwell Anderson, Kurt Weill) – 4:01
9. "Firefly" (Cy Coleman, Carolyn Leigh) – 1:39
10. "There Will Never Be Another You" (Mack Gordon, Harry Warren) – 3:16
11. "Lullaby of Broadway" (Al Dubin, Warren) – 3:13
12. "Ol' Man River" (Oscar Hammerstein II, Jerome Kern) – 5:00

• Tony Bennett – vocals

The Count Basie Orchestra:

• Thad Jones, Joe Newman, Snooky Young, Wendell Culley – trumpet
• Henry Coker, Benny Powell, Al Grey – trombone
• Marshal Royal – alto sax, clarinet
• Frank Wess – alto and tenor saxes, flute
• Frank Foster – tenor sax, flute
• Billy Mitchell – tenor sax, clarinet
• Charlie Fowlkes – baritone sax, flute, bass clarinet
• Freddie Green – electric guitar
• Ralph Sharon – piano, arranger
• Eddie Jones – double bass
• Candido Camero – bongos
• Sonny Payne – drums

• Al Ham – producer
• Didier C. Deutsch – associate producer
• Al Ham – associate producer
• Frank Laico – engineer
• Cliff Morris – engineer
• Seymour Mednick – photography
• Kevin Boutote – mastering
• Bob Burns – contractor