Mid-air collision

In aviation, a mid-air collision is an accident in which two or more aircraft come into unplanned contact during flight.[1] Owing to the relatively high velocities involved and the likelihood of subsequent impact with the ground or sea, very severe damage or the total destruction of at least one of the aircraft usually results.

2002 Überlingen mid-air collision

The potential for a mid-air collision is increased by miscommunication, mistrust, error in navigation, deviations from flight plans, lack of situational awareness, and the lack of collision-avoidance systems. Although a rare occurrence in general due to the vastness of open space available, collisions often happen near or at airports, where large volumes of aircraft are spaced more closely than in general flight.

First record

Bobbie R. Allen, Director of Safety at the Civil Aeronautics Board said in a 1965 speech - "The threat of mid-air collision has existed ever since Orville turned to Wilber and said, 'Let's build another one.'"[citation needed]

Contemporary artist's impression of the first mid-air collision, 1910

The first recorded collision between aircraft occurred at the "Milano Circuito Aereo Internazionale" meeting held between 24 September and 3 October 1910 in Milan, Italy. On 3 October, Frenchman René Thomas, flying the Antoinette IV monoplane, collided with British Army Captain Bertram Dickson by ramming his Farman III biplane in the rear.[2] Both pilots survived, but Dickson was so badly injured that he never flew again.[3][4][5]

The first fatal collision occurred over La Brayelle Airfield, Douai, France, on 19 June 1912. Captain Marcel Dubois and Lieutenant Albert Peignan, both of the French Army, crashed into one another in an early-morning haze, killing both pilots.[6][7]

Traffic collision avoidance system

Almost all modern large aircraft are fitted with a traffic collision avoidance system (TCAS), which is designed to try to prevent mid-air collisions. The system, based on the signals from aircraft transponders, alerts pilots if a potential collision with another aircraft is imminent. Despite its limitations, it is believed to have greatly reduced mid-air collisions.[8]

United States

On some occasions, military aircraft conducting training flights inadvertently collide with civilian aircraft. The 1958 collision between United Airlines Flight 736 and a fighter jet, and another U.S. military/civilian crash one month later involving Capital Airlines Flight 300, hastened the signing of the Federal Aviation Act of 1958 into law. The act created the Federal Aviation Agency (later renamed the Federal Aviation Administration), and provided unified control of airspace for both civil and military flights. In 2005, in an effort to reduce such military/civilian mid-air collisions in U.S. airspace, the Air National Guard Flight Safety Division, led by Lt Col Edward Vaughan, used the disruptive solutions process to create a website called See and Avoid. It operated until January 2017.[9]

Lists

Involving civilians

DateFatalities[N 1]Survivors[N 2]Flights involvedPhase of flightSite
1922Apr 770CGEA Farman F.60 / Daimler Hire Ltd. de Havilland DH.18A492 ftPicardy, France
1929Apr 2160Maddux Airlines Ford 5-AT-B Trimotor / US Army Air Corps Boeing PW-9D)2,000 ftSan Diego, California, United States
1935May 18450Tupolev ANT-20 Maxim Gorky / VVS Polikarpov I-5CruiseMoscow, Russian SFSR, Soviet Union
1938Aug 245 + 80 ground fatalitiesJapanese Flying School (Hanriot HD-1) and Japan Airlines Transportation (Fokker Super Universal)UnknownŌmori, Tokyo, Japan
1942Oct 23122American Airlines Flight 28 / US Army Air Force B-34Ascent/descent (9000 ft)Chino Canyon, California, United States
1945Jul 12320 Eastern Airlines Flight 45 / US Army Air Force A-26 InvaderDescentFlorence, South Carolina, United States
1948Apr 5150British European Airways Vickers VC.1 Viking / Soviet Air Force Yakovlev Yak-3 fighterApproachRAF Gatow, Berlin, Germany
1948Jul 4390Scandinavian Airlines System DC-6 / RAF Avro YorkDescentNorthwood, London, United Kingdom
1949Jan 30233Pan Am Flight 100 (Lockheed L-749 Constellation) / Cessna 140ClimbPort Washington, New York, United States
1949Feb 19140BEA Douglas Dakota / RAF Avro AnsonCruiseExhall, United Kingdom
1949Nov 1551Eastern Air Lines 537 / Lockheed P-38 test flightApproachWashington, DC, United States
1951Apr 25430Cubana de Aviación 493 / US Navy flightCruise/climbKey West, Florida, United States
1952Jun 28260American Airlines Flight 910 / private Temco SwiftApproachDallas, Texas, United States
1954Apr 8370Trans-Canada Airlines Flight 9 / RCAF HarvardCruiseMoose Jaw, Saskatchewan Canada
1955Jan 12150TWA Flight 694 / Private DC-3ClimbBoone County, Kentucky, United States
1956Jun 301280UA Flight 718 / TWA Flight 2CruiseGrand Canyon, Arizona, United States
1957Jan 3180Douglas Aircraft Company DC-7B / Northrop F-89J ScorpionCruisePacoima, Los Angeles, California, United States
1958Apr 21490United Airlines Flight 736 / USAF F-100 Super SabreCruiseLas Vegas, Nevada, United States
1958May 20131Capital Airlines Flight 300 / Air National Guard flightDescentBrunswick, Maryland, United States
1958Oct 22311British European Airways Flight 142 / Italian Air Force F-86 Sabre jet fighterDescentNear Anzio, Italy
1960Feb 25613Real Transportes Aéreos DC-3 / US Navy R6D flightDescentRio de Janeiro, Brazil
1960May 19138Air Algérie Sud Aviation SE210 Caravelle 1A / Stampe SV.4ApproachParis-Orly, France
1960Dec 161340UA Flight 826 / TWA Flight 266DescentNew York City, United States
1963Feb 11040MEA Flight 265 / Turkish Air Force flightDescentAnkara, Turkey
1965Dec 44108TWA Flight 42 / Eastern Airlines Flight 853DescentCarmel, New York, United States
1967Mar 9260TWA Flight 553 / Private flightDescentUrbana, Ohio, United States
1967Jul 19820Piedmont Airlines Flight 22 / Lanseair Inc. flightClimb/descentHendersonville, North Carolina, United States
1968Mar 27249Ozark Air Lines Flight 965 / Private flightApproachSt. Louis, Missouri, United States
1968Aug 4312North Central Airlines Flight 261 / Private flightDescent/CruiseWind Lake, Wisconsin, United States
1969Jun 231200Aeroflot Flight 831/ Soviet Air Force flightCruiseYukhnovsky District, Soviet Union
1969Sep 9820Allegheny Airlines Flight 853 / Private flightDescentFairland, Indiana, United States
1971Jun 6501Hughes Airwest Flight 706 / F-4 PhantomClimbSan Gabriel Mountains, California, United States
1971Jul 301621ANA Flight 58 / JASDF flightCruisenear Shizukuishi, Japan
1971Aug 4098Continental Airlines Flight 712 / Private Flight3,950 ftCompton, California, United States
1972Jun 29130North Central Airlines Flight 290 / Air Wisconsin Flight 671CruiseLake Winnebago, Wisconsin, United States
1972Jul 29380Avianca Flight 626  / Another Avianca Flight [10][11]CruiseNear Las Palomas, Colombia
1973Mar 568108Iberia Flight 504 / Spantax Flight 400[12]Cruisenear Nantes, France
1974Aug 930RAF Phantom FGR2 / Piper Pawnee crop dusterLow levelFordham Fen, Norfolk, United Kingdom
1974Nov 1380Antonov An-2 / Mil Mi-8ApproachNear Surgut, Soviet Union
1975Jan 9140Golden West Airlines Flight 261 / Private flightClimbnear Whittier, California, United States
1976Sep 9700Aeroflot Flight 31 / Aeroflot Flight 7957Cruisenear Anapa, Russian SFSR, Soviet Union
1976Sep 101760British Airways Flight 476 / Inex-Adria Flight 550Cruisenear Zagreb, SR Croatia, Yugoslavia
1978Sep 251440PSA Flight 182 / Private flightDescentSan Diego, California, United States
1979Aug 111780Aeroflot Flight 7628 / Aeroflot Flight 7880CruiseDniprodzerzhynsk, Ukrainian SSR, Soviet Union
1981Aug 24371Aeroflot Flight 811 / Soviet Air Force Tupolev Tu-16KCruiseZavitinsk, Russian SFSR, Soviet Union
1984Apr 181916Two VOTEC Servicios Aéreos Regionais Flights [13][14]ApproachNear Imperatriz Airport, Brazil
1984Aug 24170Wings West Airlines Flight 628 / Rockwell Commander 112Descent/climbNear San Luis Obispo, California
1985May 3940Aeroflot Flight SSSR-65856  / Soviet Air Force Antonov An-26DescentZolochev, Ukrainian SSR, Soviet Union
1986Jun 18250Grand Canyon Airlines Flight 6  / Private helicopter flight Low levelGrand Canyon, United States
1986Aug 31820Aeroméxico Flight 498 / Private flightDescent/climbCerritos, California, United States
1987Jan 15100SkyWest Airlines Flight 1834 / Private flightApproachKearns, Utah, United States
1988Aug 283 + 67 ground fatalities03 Aermacchi MB-339PAN of the Frecce TricoloriAir showRamstein Air Base, Germany
1990Apr 927ASA Flight 2254 / Private flightClimb/descentGadsden, Alabama, United States
1991Apr 450Lycoming Air Piper Aerostar / Sun Oil Company Bell 412Low levelMerion, Pennsylvania
1992Dec 221572Libyan Arab Airlines Flight 1103 / Libyan Air Force MiG-23 jet fighterApproachTripoli, Libya
1993Feb 81330Iran Air Tours Tupolev Tu-154M / Iranian Air Force Sukhoi Su-24Climb/approachTehran, Iran
1993Nov 2640NZ Police Eagle / NZ Police traffic patrolLow levelAuckland, New Zealand
1996Nov 123490Saudia Flight 763 / Kazakhstan Airlines Flight 1907Climb/descentCharkhi Dadri, India
1998Jul 30150Proteus Airlines Flight 706 / Private flightLow levelQuiberon Bay, France
2000Feb 830Zlin 242L / Cessna 172DescentZion, Illinois, United States
2002Jul 1710Bashkirian Airlines Flight 2937 / DHL Flight 611CruiseÜberlingen, Germany
2005Jan 1812Air Tractor AT-502B  / US Air Force Cessna T-37BCruiseHollister, Oklahoma, United States
2006Sep 291547[15]Gol Transportes Aéreos Flight 1907 / ExcelAire flightCruiseAmazon rainforest, Brazil
2007Mar 580Aérospatiale SA 332 Super Puma / private Diamond DV20 KatanaLow levelZell am See Airport, Austria
2007Jul 2740KNXV-TV news helicopter / KTVK news helicopterLow levelPhoenix, Arizona, United States
2007Sep 120Two Zlin Z-526Fs of the AZL ŻelaznyAerobatic displayNear Radom, Poland
2009Aug 890Piper PA-32 / Eurocopter AS350 helicopterLow levelHudson River, New York, United States
2012Sep 203200Syrian Arab Airlines Flight RB-501 / Syrian Air Force Mil Mi-8 helicopterClimbDamascus, Syria
2013Nov 2011Cessna 182L / Cessna 185FCruiseSuperior, Wisconsin, United States[16][17]
2015Mar 9100Two Eurocopter AS350 helicoptersClimbLa Rioja Province, Argentina
2015Jul 721USAF F-16 / Cesna 150Approach / ClimbMoncks Corner, South Carolina, United States
2015Sep 57112Ceiba Intercontinental Airlines Flight 71 / Senegalair business jetCruiseEastern Senegal
2019May 13610Mountain Air Service DHC-2 / Taquan Air DHC-3DescentGeorge Inlet, Alaska, United States
2020Jul 3170de Havilland DHC-2 Beaver / Piper PA-12ClimbSoldotna, Alaska, United States
2021May 1203Key Lime Air Flight 970 / Private Cirrus SR22 flightApproachArapahoe County, Colorado, United States
2022Jul 1740Piper PA-46 Malibu / Cessna 172ApproachNorth Las Vegas, Nevada, United States
2022Sep 1730Cessna 172 / Sonex XenosCruiseLongmont, Boulder County, Colorado
2022Sep 2420Zlín Z-526 / Zlín Z-526Aerobatic displayGera, Germany
2022Nov 1260Boeing B-17 Flying Fortress / Bell P-63 KingcobraClimbDallas, Texas, United States
2023Jan 249Two Eurocopter EC130 helicoptersClimb/descentGold Coast Seaway, Queensland, Australia
2023Mar 740 Piper PA28-161 Cadet / Piper J-3 CubClimb/DescentWinter Haven, Florida, United States

Purely military

XB-70 Valkyrie 62-0207 following the mid-air collision on 8 June 1966: The XB-70 can be seen at the far left of the image, missing one of its vertical stabilizers, while the large fireball is the F-104 Starfighter with which it collided.
DateFatalities[N 1]Survivors[N 2]Aircraft involvedSite
1940Sep 2904Two Avro Ansons of the RAAFBrocklesby, New South Wales, Australia
1953Jan 15260RAF Vickers Valetta / RAF Avro LancasterMediterranean Sea near Sicily
1955Aug 11660Two USAF C-119 Flying Boxcarsnear Stuttgart, Germany
1958Feb 504USAF B-47 Stratojet / USAF F-86 SabreTybee Island, Georgia, U.S.
1965Jun 15180Two U.S. Army UH-1D IroquoisesFort Benning, Georgia, U.S.
1966Jan 1774USAF B-52G Stratofortress / USAF KC-135 StratotankerMediterranean Sea near Palomares, Almería, Spain
1983May 103Israeli Air Force F-15 Eagle / A-4 SkyhawkNegev, Israel
1988Aug 2870[N 3]0Three Aermacchi MB-339PAN aircraft of the Frecce TricoloriRamstein Air Base, Germany
1994Mar 2324[N 4]7F-16 Fighting Falcon / C-130 HerculesPope Air Force Base, North Carolina, U.S.
1997Feb 4730Two IAF Sikorsky CH-53 helicoptersShe'ar Yashuv, Israel
1997Sep 13330USAF C-141B Starlifter / German Air Force Tupolev Tu-154MOff the coast of Namibia
2001Apr 1124USN Lockheed EP-3E / PLAN Shenyang J-8IISouth China Sea near Hainan Island, PRC
2009Aug 1611Two Sukhoi Su-27s of the Russian KnightsMoscow, Russia
2009Oct 3090USCG C-130 / USMC Cobra HelicopterOff the coast of California, U.S.
2014Jun 2321Learjet 35A / Eurofighter TyphoonOlsberg, Germany
2019Nov 25130French Armed Forces Eurocopter Tiger / Eurocopter AS532 CougarMénaka, Ménaka Region, Mali
2022Nov 1260B-17 Flying Fortress / Bell P-63 KingcobraDallas, Texas, U.S.
2023April 273[18]1Two AH-64 ApacheHealy, Alaska, U.S.
2023Jul 111Two T-27 TucanoVillavicencio, Meta, Colombia
2023Aug 253[19]?Two L-39 AlbatrosZhytomyr oblast, Ukraine

See also

References

Notes
Citations
Bibliography
  • Gero, David B. & Sparkford, Yoevil (2010). Military Aviation Disasters: Significant Losses Since 1908. Somerset, UK: Haynes Publishing. ISBN 978-1-84425-645-7.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)

External links