Shark fin soup

Traditional shark fin soup or stew is made with fins obtained from a variety of shark species. Raw fins are processed by first removing the skin and denticles before trimming them into shapes and bleaching to a more desirable coloration.^[9]

Sharks' fins are sold dried, cooked, wet, and frozen. Ready-to-eat shark fin soup is also readily available in Asian markets.^[9]

Dried fins come in cooked and skinned (shredded) and raw and unskinned (whole), the latter requiring more preparation.^[10] Both need to be softened before they can be used to prepare soup.

The taste of the soup comes from the broth, as the fins themselves are almost tasteless.^[11] Rather than for taste, the fins are used for their "snappy, gelatinous" texture,^[11] which has been described as "chewy, sinewy, stringy".^[4] Krista Mahr of Time called it "somewhere between chewy and crunchy".^[12]

Shark fins are believed in Chinese culture to have properties of boosting sexual potency, enhancing skin quality, increasing qi or energy, preventing heart disease, and lowering cholesterol.^[13] In traditional Chinese medicine, shark fins are believed to help in areas of rejuvenation, appetite enhancement, and blood nourishment and to be beneficial to vital energy, kidneys, lungs, bones, and many other parts of the body.^[9]

There are claims that shark fins prevent cancer;^[14] however, there is no scientific evidence, and one study found shark cartilage generally to be of no value in cancer treatment.^[15] Furthermore, there is no scientific evidence that shark fins can be used to treat any medical condition.^[9] Sharks biomagnify toxins, so eating shark meat may raise the risk of dementia and mercury poisoning.^{[16][17][18][19]}

WildAid, a wildlife non-governmental organization, warned that eating too much shark fin can cause sterility in men.^[17] It is known that larger fish such as shark, tuna, and swordfish contain high levels of mercury and methylmercury salts.^[16] For nursing mothers, young children, and pregnant women or those who wish to be, the United States Food and Drug Administration has advised avoiding consumption of fish high in mercury.^[20][21]

High concentrations of BMAA are present in shark fins. Because BMAA is a neurotoxin, consumption of shark fin soup and cartilage pills may pose a risk for degenerative brain diseases such as Alzheimer's and ALS,^[18][19] as well as Parkinson's disease.^[18]

Counterfeit shark fins often also contain toxins.^[22]

Early use

Shark fin soup was reported in Ming dynasty writings and by the Qing dynasty was considered a "traditional part of formal banquets"; in Chinese cuisine, it was considered to be one of the eight treasured foods from the sea.^[23] It was popular with Chinese emperors because it was rare, and tasty only after a complicated and elaborate preparation.^[24] By the time of the Qing dynasty, shark fin soup was in high demand.^[25][26] Its manual of cuisine, the Suiyuan shidan, indicates that the shark fin was eaten as soup, stew, and even as a stir-fry, but in all cases the fin had to be boiled for two days.^[27]

The popularity of shark fin soup rose in the late-18th and early-19th centuries as standards of living began to improve.^[4]

Demand peaks, c. 2000

In the late-20th century, shark fin soup was a popular delicacy in China, and was eaten in Chinese restaurants around the world.^[28][29] The increasing wealth of the middle class raised demand.^[30] The shark fin trade more than doubled between 1985 and 2001.^[31]

Based on information gathered from the Hong Kong trade in fins, the market was estimated in 2004 to be growing by five percent each year.^[32] Consumption of shark fin soup had risen dramatically with the affluence of the middle class, as Chinese communities around the world enjoyed increasing income levels.^[4][31][33] The high price of the soup meant it was often used as a way to impress guests, or for celebrations^[34] such as weddings, banquets, and important business deals.^[24][35][36] It was used to communicate wealth, power, and prestige,^[35][36] as it was believed to show respect, honor, and appreciation to guests as well as to intimidate them as the serving of such a dish often implies that the host is willing to use cruelty and brutality to achieve their goals,^[24][13] with 58% of those questioned in the WWF survey indicating they ate the soup at a celebration or gathering.^[37]

In Hong Kong restaurants, where the market had been strong, demand from Hong Kong natives had reportedly dropped in 2006. This was more than balanced by an increase in demand from the Chinese mainland,^[34] where economic growth put the expensive delicacy within the reach of an expanding middle class.^[30]

A survey carried out in China in 2006 by WildAid and the Chinese Wildlife Conservation Association found that 35% of participants said they had consumed shark fin soup in the last year,^[28] while 83% of participants in an online survey conducted by the World Wide Fund for Nature said that they had consumed shark fin soup at some time.^[37]

Changes in demand, 2005–present

The movement against shark fin soup began in 2006, when WildAid enlisted Chinese basketball star Yao Ming as spokesperson for a public relations campaign against the dish. The campaign was taken up by a coalition of Chinese businessmen, celebrities, and students. Businessman-turned-environmentalist Jim Zhang helped to raise concern within China's government, which pledged in 2012 to ban shark fin soup from official banquets within three years.^[38]

In January 2013, China Daily reported that officials in Zhejiang province found that many shark fin soup restaurants were selling artificial shark fins, and that one-third of the samples that the officials had obtained contained dangerous amounts of cadmium and methylmercury.^{[22][unreliable source?]} Within two months of the China Daily report, China ordered officials throughout the country to stop serving dishes made from protected wildlife at official banquets, and the Hong Kong government issued a similar order in September.^[38]

Consumption of shark fin soup in China has decreased. China's Ministry of Commerce indicated that consumption of shark fin soup during the 2013 spring break holiday had decreased by 50–70% from 2012, and Hong Kong industry groups reported that shark fin imports were down by 20–30% from 2012.^[38] Also, anecdotal evidence points to a worldwide drop in shark fin prices and a move away from shark fishing in parts of Africa.^[38] Shark fin soup has often been replaced by dishes featuring sea cucumbers.^[39]: 270

A 2016 poll from City University of Hong Kong and the Hong Kong Shark Foundation had 75% of local respondents saying they were "neutral" towards the soup at banquets,^[40] while 90% of respondents said they would eat the dish if served to them, with the most popular justifications being to “avoid food waste” or to “show respect for their host”.^[41]

A 2018 WildAid report mentioned Thailand as an emerging market for shark fin soup, citing a 2017 survey where 57% of urban Thai respondents consumed the dish, most commonly at weddings, restaurants, and business meetings.^[42]

Shark fins used in the soup are the cartilaginous dorsal, pectoral and caudal fins. These are regularly harvested by a process known as shark finning, which takes only the fins and discards the carcass, alive or dead. Overfishing poses a major threat to the world's shark populations.^[43]

Some groups, such as Fins Attached, Shark Savers, IUCN, Shark Angels, Shark Whisperer and the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, discourage consumption of the soup due to concerns with the world's shark population and how sharks are inhumanely finned alive and returned to the ocean, unable to swim, hunt or survive. The prevalence of shark finning and the sustainability of shark species are both debated.^[44][45][46] As of 2011, major hotel operators such as Marriott International, The Peninsula Hotels and Shangri-La Hotels and Resorts stopped serving shark fin soup in favor of offering sustainable seafood.^[47][48] The largest supermarket chains in Singapore – Cold Storage and NTUC FairPrice – have stopped selling shark fins, citing sustainability concerns.^[49] Hong Kong Disneyland dropped the soup from its menu after it could not find a sustainable source.^[50]

Malaysia's Natural Resources and Environment Ministry banned shark fin soup from official functions in a commitment to the Malaysian Nature Society to conserve the shark species.^[51]

In the United States, Hawaii,^[52] Washington,^[53] Oregon,^[54][55] California,^[56] Guam,^[57] and the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands have banned the sale and possession of shark fins, effectively eliminating the availability of the soup.^[58] Illinois, which had been a large importer of shark fins, was the fifth U.S. state, and the first non-Pacific state, to implement a ban on shark fin trade.^[59] In 2011, U.S. President Barack Obama signed the Shark Conservation Act, closing loopholes used to obtain shark fins.^[60] In October 2011, California governor Jerry Brown, citing the cruelty of finning and potential threats to the environment and commercial fishing, signed Assembly Bill 376, banning the possession and sale of detached shark fins.^[56][61] Two Chinese American groups challenged the law in federal court, arguing among other things that it was discriminatory against the Chinese-American community. The federal courts rejected these claims.^[62]

In Canada, the Vancouver city council decided to work towards creating a ban to preserve shark species.^[63] Toronto joined other regional municipalities in adopting a shark fin ban on 13 October 2011.^[64] The Ontario Superior Court of Justice overturned the Toronto bylaw, as it was outside the powers of the city.^[65] Calgary banned shark fin soup on 16 July 2012,^[66] but in May 2013 shelved the bylaw indefinitely.^[67]

On 2 July 2012, the State Council of the People's Republic of China declared that shark fin soup can no longer be served at official banquets. This ban may take up to three years to take effect because of the social significance of the dish in Chinese culture.^[68]

The marine conservation organization Bite-Back has campaigned against the sale of shark fin soup in Britain. On the back of its campaigning, the London-based Michelin-starred Chinese restaurant Hakkasan agreed to stop selling the soup.^[69] High-profile names such as Gordon Ramsay, Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall, and Charles Clover, author of The End of the Line: How Overfishing Is Changing the World and What We Eat, have lent their support to the charity's 'Hacked Off' campaign.^[70] In 2019, environmental NGO WildAid partnered with Plan B Media on a public awareness campaign to discourage sharkfin soup consumption in Taiwan.^[71]

Imitation shark fin soup

A bowl of imitation shark fin soup, served in 2020 in California for a Chinese American family during the eve of Chinese New Year.
Alternative names	Mock shark fin soup, vegetarian shark fin soup
Type	Soup
Place of origin	China
Region or state	Hong Kong
Main ingredients	Imitation shark fins (may use konjac gel, cellophane noodles, vermicelli, shark fin melon, or other alternatives), broth
Cookbook: Imitation shark fin soup   Media: Imitation shark fin soup

Imitation shark fin soup is a noodle soup often sold in small bowls by street vendors in Hong Kong, where it is a common street snack. It is a more ethical and affordable substitute for shark fin soup.^[72]

A popular, low-cost imitation shark fin soup (碗仔翅) made using vermicelli is widely available in Asia.^[73][74] They can also be made from cellophane noodles.^[75][11] Seafood companies in Asia later developed edible gelatinous products to imitate shark fins' qualities, commonly referred as "imitation shark fins".

Imitation shark fins

Substitutes for shark include imitation shark fin, konjac gel, various forms of noodles, and others. "Mock shark's fin" soup appeared in Hong Kong during the 1970s. From the 1990s onward, it became popular in restaurants throughout China. The shark fin is replaced with an imitation and edible mushrooms, kelps, seaweeds, bean sprouts, bamboo shoots, and beaten eggs are added, as in the traditional soup.

Imitation shark fin (素翅), typically from Japan, Hong Kong, and Taiwan, is known as sùchì in Chinese Mandarin and sou ci in Chinese Cantonese, literally means "vegetarian fin". A Taiwanese manufacturer's recipe for it contains water, gelatin, alginic acid, sugar, casein, and triolein to reproduce the chewy, gelatinous texture of shark fins. However, some of these imitations absorb the broth more quickly than the real shark fin.^[76] Konjac gel (known as moyu tofu in Chinese Mandarin, mo wu dau fu in Chinese Cantonese, and konnyaku in Japanese) can also be used as a substitute for shark fin once it is julienned into thin strands using a chef's knife, produce slicer, or food processor.^[77][78] While cellophane noodles are also often used as an alternative to shark fins,^[75] some cooks find them too soft and unable to withstand simmering long enough for flavors to be absorbed, consequently the imitation shark fin or julienned konjac gel are more desirable. Other substitutes include Cucurbita ficifolia (shark fin melon, shark fin soup squash), chicken breast, jinhua ham, vermicelli, soy, sea cucumber, bird's nest, pig's skin and gelatin.^[79]

In 2015, a seafood company from San Francisco was working on a variation of imitation shark fin using algae-derived ingredients and recombinant proteins.^[80]

Alternatives to shark fin are inexpensive and easier to prepare. Imitation shark fin, konjac gel, and other alternatives can be purchased in preserved form from Asian supermarkets and convenience stores.

History

Imitation shark fin soup originated from Temple Street in Hong Kong during the 1950s and 1960s.^[72] Few people at that time could afford genuine shark fin soup, but street vendors collected the broken parts of shark fins discarded by Chinese restaurants and cooked them with mushrooms, egg, and pork, as well as soy sauce and other ingredients. The mixture, which was cooked into a soup, was served in a small bowl. Although this soup was inexpensive and lacked the authentic flavor, since it was cheap, tasty and contained many ingredients, it was popular among the poor and became one of the famous street snacks of Hong Kong.

Apart from the street vendor version, imitation shark fin soup may also be found in fast-food stores and expensive Chinese restaurants in Hong Kong, and also on mainland China. Since April 2016, Cup Noodles released various instant imitation shark fin ramen soups.^[81]

Controversy

False descriptions of goods and services are prohibited by the Trade Descriptions Ordinance in Hong Kong.^[82] Thus, imitation shark fin soup may have to change its Cantonese name since "wun tsai chi" (碗仔翅 literally: "fin in little bowl") may mislead customers into thinking there is real shark fin in it. However, many argue against this new policy; some claim that the name is tied to the Hong Kong people's collective memories and culture, representing the history of old Hong Kong. It would also be inconvenient for tourists seeking the dish. Opponents of the name change suggest the government should consider whether customers are misled before carrying out the policy.

• Bird's nest soup
• Buddha Jumps Over the Wall, a soup containing shark fin
• Endangered sharks; many sharks are endangered as a consequence of the market for shark fins
• List of Chinese soups
• Sharkfin and prawn dumpling in superior soup
• Shark meat
• Sharkwater, 2006 documentary film
• United States v. Approximately 64,695 Pounds of Shark Fins, a 2008 court decision
• Three grand soups
• Shark finning

• Baum J.K., Myers R.A., Kehler D.G., Worm B., Harley S.J., Doherty P.A. (2003) "Collapse and conservation of shark populations in the Northwest Atlantic". Science, 299 (5605): 389–392. doi:10.1126/science.1079777

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Shark fin soup.

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Vegetarian shark fin soup.

• Decimating Shark Population for Some Soup – ABC News, 30 October 2006
• Fisherman holds shark fin – by The Smithsonian Institution: Ocean Portal
• How Sharks Have Paid the Price for Demand for Shark Fin Soup – at the Voice of America's Special English Branch
• Shark Truth Archived 22 January 2012 at the Wayback Machine – a grassroots nonprofit dedicated to promoting awareness, education, and action about shark fin soup in the Chinese community
• 'Fin – help end the horror' – anti-shark-finning advert produced by Ogilvy & Mather for Bite-Back